My Friendship with Arthur Saxon by Thomas Inch

Latest announcements and news from the History of Physical Culture.

Moderators: DannyBoy, Harry Hayfield, drob357

Post Reply
User avatar
drob357
Site Admin
Posts: 295
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2014 5:54 pm
Location: British Columbia, Canada
Contact:

My Friendship with Arthur Saxon by Thomas Inch

Post by drob357 » Thu Aug 08, 2019 11:06 pm

HISTORY OF PHYSICAL CULTURE LIBRARY
Subscribe: www.DavidGentle.com

Image

It was well known that Thomas Inch became good friends with the Saxons and benefited from their advise and experience. This piece gives testimony to those facts, However in my opinion it is marred by the claim near the end that Arthur Saxon was never able to lift Inch's famous challenge Dumbbell.

As we see the year of writing is 1952 long after Arthur had died and unable to refute that claim. To my knowledge and that of others who have some understanding of the subject nothing of the nature was ever mentioned while Saxon was alive. Knowing the raw strength of Arthur Saxon and his mighty grip, I personally feel sure that if he had tried the bell in question then he would have at the very least raised it of the ground as in a deadlift.

So he either never tried, which considering he was friends with Inch seems unlikely, or he did it in private but did not take credit in deference to his friend's reputation. Having nothing to prove I feel the latter most likely. If that was the case it would have been best if Inch had never mentioned it at all. Of course, this is just my opinion but one that seems likely. - Peter Yates, HOPC Editor-in-Chief.
Subscribe: www.davidgentle.com
Diane Robert
Chief Librarian/Site Administrator
https://davidgentle.com

Post Reply